It started as a quiet Saturday morning garage sale — until a small silver coin caught someone’s eye. Within minutes, whispers turned to gasps as word spread: the coin might be worth far more than its $1 face value. What followed was an unexpected bidding war over a rare Susan B. Anthony Dollar that turned an ordinary sale into a collector’s showdown.
What Is the Susan B. Anthony Dollar?
The Susan B. Anthony Dollar, minted between 1979 and 1981 and again in 1999, was America’s first coin to feature a real woman rather than a symbolic figure. Though often mistaken for a quarter due to its size and color, it carries rich historical significance — honoring a pioneering suffragist who fought for women’s rights.
A Short History of This Underrated Coin
When first introduced, the Susan B. Anthony Dollar aimed to replace paper $1 bills. However, the public rejected it, finding it too similar to quarters. Many coins remained stored in vaults, making certain years and mint marks unexpectedly rare today. In recent years, collectors have rediscovered the series, driving up demand and value.
Why This Garage Sale Coin Was Special
Not every Susan B. Anthony Dollar is valuable — but specific mint marks and conditions can make some worth hundreds or even thousands. The coin spotted at the garage sale was rumored to be a 1979-P Wide Rim or possibly a proof strike, both highly sought-after by collectors. Its near-perfect condition and sharp details only fueled the excitement.
From $1 to Hundreds: The Bidding War Begins
What began as a casual find quickly escalated. The seller, unaware of its potential, listed the coin for $1. But within moments, bidders recognized its rarity, pushing the price higher and higher. Neighbors gathered, phones came out, and before long, the once-overlooked dollar coin fetched several hundred dollars — possibly more than the entire garage sale combined.
Valuable Susan B. Anthony Dollar Varieties
| Year | Mint Mark | Variety / Feature | Approx. Value (Uncirculated) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1979 | P | Wide Rim / Near Date | $100 – $600+ |
| 1979 | S | Proof Type 2 (Clear S) | $150 – $300+ |
| 1981 | S | Proof Type 2 (Clear S) | $250 – $400+ |
| 1999 | P / D | Low Mintage | $10 – $50+ |
How to Identify Valuable Susan B. Anthony Dollars
- Check the Date and Mint Mark – Look closely near the coin’s edge for “P,” “D,” or “S.”
- Look for the Wide Rim (1979-P) – The date appears closer to the rim than usual.
- Inspect the “S” on Proof Coins – A clear “S” mint mark indicates a valuable Type 2 variety.
- Evaluate Condition – Coins with minimal wear and sharp details fetch premium prices.
Collector Tips & Grading Insights
| Tip | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Grading | Have coins graded by PCGS or NGC for authenticity |
| Storage | Use protective holders to prevent scratches |
| Research Market Trends | Coin values fluctuate — monitor auctions |
| Avoid Cleaning | Cleaning can reduce value significantly |
| Compare with Reputable Sources | Check auction listings and collector guides |
Why Collectors Are Paying More Now
Interest in modern US dollar coins has surged, as more hobbyists recognize their undervalued potential. With the Susan B. Anthony Dollar’s feminist legacy, low surviving mintages, and rare varieties, its market value continues to rise — especially for certified coins.
Expert Insights: Don’t Overlook the “Small Dollar”
Seasoned numismatists say coins like the Susan B. Anthony Dollar often go unnoticed in collections or loose change, yet hold surprising worth. Many advise checking garage sales, estate boxes, and old coin jars — you never know when a hidden gem might surface.
FAQs
Q: Are all Susan B. Anthony Dollars valuable?
A: No, most are common, but key varieties like the 1979-P Wide Rim or 1981-S Proof Type 2 can be worth hundreds.
Q: Where can I sell one?
A: Reputable auction houses, coin dealers, or certified marketplaces like eBay with PCGS grading.
Q: Should I clean my coin before selling?
A: Never. Cleaning damages the surface and decreases value.
Conclusion: The $1 Coin That Stole the Show
What began as a simple garage sale became a thrilling reminder of how ordinary coins can hold extraordinary stories. The Susan B. Anthony Dollar, once overlooked, now stands as a symbol of hidden value and history. Before you pass up the next coin you see, take a closer look — your spare change might be worth far more than you think.